6 Best Restaurants in Garden City

Garden City, a vibrant community tucked away in the heart of Long Island, offers a delightful culinary landscape that mirrors the city's charm and spirit. The thriving food scene ranges from homely diners to avant-garde bistros, all with a shared passion for good food. Here, we take you on a gastronomic journey through ten of the most enchanting Garden City restaurants, each unique in its own delicious way.


Sparrow Kitchen & Cocktails is a charming spot in Garden City, with a menu inspired by seasonally available produce, aiming to support local farms. Their offerings include a variety of small plates that pair well with their extensive list of cocktails, beers, and wines.

The ambiance at Sparrow Kitchen & Cocktails is modern and beautiful, with touches reflecting Long Island's coastal charm, which seems to be a welcome addition to the downtown dining scene of Garden City. Blending a contemporary dining experience with a cozy ambiance, Sparrow is a delightful choice for those exploring fine cuisines in Garden City.

Leo's Tavern

Leo's Tavern, also known as Leo's Midway, brands itself with the tagline "Good Food. Great Times" and offers a variety of beverages, including a dozen beers on tap, specialty cocktails, a curated wine selection, and a full bar. It operates as a traditional American restaurant and sports bar, serving various dishes such as burgers and steaks, and offers features like a rotating beer selection. The restaurant offers a casual, friendly atmosphere suitable for both happy hours and family dinners.

Leo's Midway has been a staple in the Garden City community since 1942, providing a diverse menu served by warm and friendly staff. The menu includes a range of items from steaks, pasta dishes, and burgers to draft beer and more, catering to a broad audience.

La Nonna Bella

The name "La Nonna Bella" translates to "The Beautiful Grandma" in Italian, emphasizing traditional, home-cooked Italian recipes. La Nonna Bella prides itself on delivering an authentic Italian dining experience and offers a menu steeped in traditional Italian dishes, from classic pasta creations to signature entrees inspired by various Italian regions. There is a warmth and tradition found here—and the kind of recipes passed down through generations. With a focus on using fresh, high-quality ingredients to recreate the flavors of Italy. The cozy ambiance, with an old-world charm reminiscent of an Italian trattoria, makes diners feel they've been transported straight to Italy.

Prime Steakhouse and Sushi

Prime Steakhouse and Sushi in Garden City likely offers an upscale dining experience that blends the rich and savory world of steakhouses with the delicate and refined art of sushi preparation. They pride themselves on serving high-quality cuts of meat sourced from the best farms and aged to perfection. The sushi component offers a variety of rolls, sashimi, and nigiri, prepared with fresh, high-grade fish. The juxtaposition of hearty steaks with light sushi often provides diners with a broad spectrum of flavors and textures, catering to a wide range of tastes. The sophisticated and contemporary ambiance makes it suitable for special occasions, business dinners, or romantic outings.


Venture into the rustic charm of Smok-Haus, an eatery that has found the perfect balance between tradition and innovation. This barbecue haven invites its guests to a warm and welcoming environment adorned with distressed wood and vintage decorations, creating an ambiance reminiscent of a classic Southern barbecue joint.

The restaurant’s menu is a testament to the art of slow cooking and smoking, featuring an array of meats that are pit-smoked daily over hickory, cherry, and apple woods. Their brisket, ribs, and pulled pork are notable crowd-pleasers, celebrated for their juiciness and the deep, smoky flavors that permeate every bite. Pair these with the house's signature sides like mac 'n' cheese or coleslaw for a fulfilling meal. With such an inviting atmosphere and expertly cooked dishes, Smok-Haus is the perfect spot for a laid-back dinner where the portions are generous, and the flavors are hearty and satisfying.

Revel Restaurant & Bar

Step into the sophisticated ambiance of Revel Restaurant & Bar, where contemporary design meets culinary excellence. The restaurant's sleek, minimalist decor exudes a modern chic charm that is both inviting and stylish, creating a backdrop that enhances every dining experience. Revel’s menu is an ode to fresh, locally sourced produce crafted into artful dishes that please the palate and the eye alike.

Menu favorites include seared scallops served over risotto and succulent steaks cooked to perfection. A sophisticated bar area serves a broad selection of cocktails, from timeless classics to creative concoctions curated by talented mixologists. The elegant dining, innovative drinks, and vibrant atmosphere make Revel a must-visit for those seeking memorable evenings filled with fine food and lively conversation.

About Laura Carroll

Laura Carroll is renowned for creating lasting, trustful relationships and delivering exceptional customer service in her real estate career. With over a decade of experience serving Garden City and Nassau County, Laura leverages her extensive financial background, including Wall Street experience, to her real estate clients' advantage.

Laura's remarkable achievements include a place on Real Trends Top 500 in NY State for three consecutive years and an impressive $500 million in real estate sales, with $100 million recorded in 2021 alone.

If you want to buy or sell a home or have questions about the Garden City real estate market, contact The Laura Carroll Team today.

Laura Carroll

Laura Carroll

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

About The Author

Building trusting relationships while providing exceptional customer service. These are just some of the many things you can expect when working with Laura Carroll and her team. Primarily serving Garden City and Nassau County, Laura has over 10+ of experience connecting clients to their dream homes–coupled with her rich financial background, which she uses for the benefit of her clients. 
Born and raised in Princeton, New Jersey, Laura has lived in Garden City with her husband Glenn and their three kids for the past decade. She began her real estate career ten years ago when she and her family moved from Pittsburgh to Garden City. Prior to becoming a real estate agent, Laura had an extensive background in finance, working for Wall Street, before she decided to go in a different direction in her life. She has not looked back since and is proud of the real estate career she has built.  Through many years of hard work and dedication, she earned a place on Real Trends Top 500 in NY State for the past three years and has sold over $500 million in real estate and $100 million alone in 2021. When working with her clients, Laura likes to lead with the philosophy “Relationships First.” Not only does she take the time to get to know her clients and their individual needs, but she also builds rapport with fellow agents, which gives her buyers and sellers the best real estate transactions possible. 
Laura is a Garden City real estate agent that is deeply passionate about her work as a real estate broker. Having built her team from the ground up, she is exceptionally proud of all the work she and her team have done to help their clients achieve their real estate goals. Laura specializes in working with buyers and sellers in Garden City and Nassau County, particularly Rockville Centre, Manhasset, Port Washington, and the surrounding area. 
In addition to being a successful broker and Garden City real estate agent, Laura is a highly active member of the community. She spends a lot of time supporting her kids in their sporting and extracurricular activities. She is also a board member and advocate for the Children’s Miracle Fund of Long Island, a beneficiary of Cohen Childrens’ Hospital. When she isn’t conducting real estate transactions, you can find Laura spending quality time with her family, grabbing coffee with one of her friends, going hiking on the north shore, and jogging outside.

Work With Laura

Holding nine years of financial and sales experience working on Wall Street, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson Laura has expertise working with a diverse community of clients.

Let's Connect